1. Positive administrative silence cannot be disregarded by subsequent acts of the entity:
Resolución 0080-2026/CEB-INDECOPI-JUN | 7 de agosto de 2026
Roosevelt Héctor Gamarra Gavilán contra Municipalidad | Provincial de Huancayo
Bureaucratic barrier analyzed
The disregard of the positive administrative silence that operated on an application for a medium-risk Building Safety Technical Inspection (ITSE) for an establishment, embodied in five administrative acts.
What did INDECOPI decide?
It declared the measure illegal. The application was filed on January 7, 2026 and the Municipality had nine business days to decide and five additional days to give notice. As it did not issue a decision within that period, positive administrative silence operated. The acts issued subsequently disregarded that deemed right, violating articles 33-A and 188 of the TUO of Law 27444. The request to order the issuance of the ITSE certificate was dismissed, as the Commission only declares barriers inapplicable. It was specified that the Municipality retains its powers of subsequent inspection and control, and may assess the nullity or revocation of the deemed authorization in accordance with the law.
Relevance
Entities cannot disregard the effects of positive administrative silence through acts issued after the deadline to decide has expired. If they consider the deemed authorization to be irregular, they must activate the nullity or revocation mechanisms provided for in the legal system, not simply ignore it.
2. Reporting debts to credit bureaus requires express legal authorization:
Resolución 0313-2026/CEB-INDECOPI | 7 de agosto de 2026
Agrícola La Candelaria S.A. vs. Superintendencia Nacional de Fiscalización Laboral (Sunafil)
Bureaucratic barrier analyzed
La limitación de someter al administrado a un registro negativo en una central de riesgos por el incumplimiento de pago de una multa administrativa por infracción laboral en etapa no coactiva, materializada en el Requerimiento de Pago 06061-2025-SUNAFIL/GG/OAD/UCEC y en la Carta 000798-2025-SUNAFIL/GG/OAD/UCEC, emitidos con base en la Directiva 002-2021-SUNAFIL/OAD-UCEC.
What did INDECOPI decide?
It declared the measure illegal. Although Sunafil has powers to sanction the
non-compliance with social and labor regulations and to coercively collect its fines, it lacks legal authority to report debts to credit bureaus. That power does not derive from a rule with the rank of law, but from a superintendency resolution and an internal directive, which contravenes the principle of legality set forth in the TUO of Law 27444. The measure was declared inapplicable in favor of the complainant, and a corrective measure of informing regulated parties and the payment of costs and fees were ordered.
Relevance
Administrative entities may only exercise the powers expressly granted to them by law. A pressure mechanism for debt collection, such as reporting to credit bureaus, cannot be created through sub-legal regulations.
3. A municipality cannot restrict the academic offering of higher education institutes:
Resolución 0315-2026/CEB-INDECOPI | 7 de agosto de 2026
Diez Canseco & Venero Abogados S.C.R.L. vs. Municipalidad Metropolitana de Lima
Bureaucratic barrier analyzed
The restriction that limited the “NON-UNIVERSITY HIGHER EDUCATION” business activity in the Historic Center of Lima to only those programs that promote cultural and tourism activity (tourism, gastronomy, hospitality, restoration, heritage, history, visual arts, performing arts and music, and languages), embodied in ISIC Code P85301 of Annex 6 of the Single Regulations for the Administration of the Historic Center of Lima, approved by Ordinance 2195-MML.
What did INDECOPI decide?
It declared the measure an illegal bureaucratic barrier and ordered its inapplicability with general effects. The Metropolitan Municipality of Lima has competence to regulate land use and protect cultural heritage, but not to decide which academic programs non-university higher education institutes may offer. That power belongs to the Ministry of Education, through the licensing procedure. By imposing the restriction, the Municipality exceeded its competences, violated the principle of legality and affected free private initiative.
Relevance
Public entities cannot condition the exercise of economic activities by invoking generic urban planning or heritage protection competences when the specific regulation of the activity belongs to another authority. Every restriction must have express legal backing.
4. A TUPA administrative procedure cannot be created by a body of the entity that lacks competence to approve it:
Resolución 0340-2026/SEL-INDECOPI | 10 de julio de 2026
Universidad Privada Norbert Wiener S.A. y otras contra Superintendencia Nacional de Educación Superior Universitaria (Sunedu)
Bureaucratic barrier analyzed
The complainants challenged five measures implemented by Sunedu, relating to the procedure “Registration of the modification of the academic offering of universities and graduate schools” (TUPA Code PA48001840) and the procedure “Modification of Institutional License (Creation of Branch)” (TUPA Code PA48002D44):
(i) la exigencia de tramitar el registro como procedimiento de evaluación previa, materializada tanto en el TUPA como en el artículo 1 de la Resolución de Superintendencia 008-2025-SUNEDU, que aprueba la Directiva para dicho registro, difundida únicamente en el portal institucional de la Sunedu;
(ii) la aplicación del silencio administrativo negativo al mismo procedimiento, materializada en el TUPA;
(iii) la exigencia de exponer ante la Sunedu el cumplimiento de las Condiciones Básicas de Calidad, materializada únicamente en el artículo 7.1, inciso b), numeral b.1, de la referida Directiva;
(iv) el cobro de S/ 5,110.70 por la tramitación del registro; y
(v) el cobro de S/ 125,844.70 por la tramitación de la modificación de licencia institucional por creación de filial.
What did INDECOPI decide?
On other grounds, however, it upheld the first-instance decision, declaring as illegal bureaucratic barriers the measures
(i) la exigencia de tramitar el procedimiento de registro de modificación de la oferta académica
(ii) el silencio administrativo negativo aplicable al referido procedimiento: si bien la incorporación formal de este procedimiento al TUPA fue aprobada mediante Resolución de Consejo Directivo, su contenido sustantivo (objeto, requisitos, documentación y plazos) proviene de la misma Directiva, aprobada por Resolución de Superintendencia, pese a que el artículo 17.1 de la Ley 30220 reserva al Consejo Directivo (órgano de mayor jerarquía de la Sunedu) la aprobación de procedimientos administrativos y sus requisitos, conforme al artículo 36 del TUO de la Ley 27444.
It also upheld the illegality of the charges of S/5,110.70 and S/ 125,844.70, since Sunedu did not prove that those amounts had been determined in accordance with the mandatory cost methodology approved by Supreme Decree 064-2010- PCM, contravening numerals 44.6 of article 44 and 45.1 of article 45 of the TUO of Law 27444.
Finally, it ordered the inapplicability with general effects of the measures confirmed as illegal and ordered, as a corrective measure, that Sunedu refund to the complainant universities, within 15 business days, the proven charges of S/ 5,110.70.
Relevance
It is not enough for an entity to have legal authorization to regulate a matter; the procedure must be created by the competent body within the entity itself. In this case, it was up to Sunedu's Board of Directors, and not the Superintendent. Furthermore, the mere inclusion of a fee in Sunedu's TUPA is not enough to support its collection, as the entity must prove that its calculation was made in accordance with the mandatory cost methodology.
The decision is also relevant because the refund of the fees charged was ordered, with identification of the payments to be returned, giving the decision concrete and not merely declaratory effects.
5. Electricity concessionaires cannot again require technical documents that they themselves already issued or approved:
Resolución 0382-2026/SEL-INDECOPI | 17 de julio de 2026
Yachaywasi Gestión y Consultoría S.A.C. contra Empresa Regional de Servicio Público de Electricidad | Electronortemedio S.A. – Hidrandina
Bureaucratic barrier analyzed
To process the refund of a reimbursable contribution for electrification works already carried out, Hidrandina required the complainant to:
(i) submit a polygonal plan in AutoCAD with UTM coordinates;
(ii) request again the electrical feasibility and design point;
(iii) process again the approval of the project; and (iv) process again the acceptance of the works, in accordance with the Procedures Standard approved by Directorial Resolution 018-2002-EM/DGE.
What did INDECOPI decide?
La Sala confirmó, bajo otros fundamentos, la Resolución 0001-2026/CEB-INDECOPI-LAL que había declarado ilegales las cuatro medidas. Precisó que el parámetro de legalidad aplicable no era el invocado por la primera instancia, sino los numerales 40.1.1 y 40.1.2 del artículo 40 del TUO de la Ley 27444, que prohíben solicitar a los administrados documentación que la entidad ya posee, genera en ejercicio de sus funciones o ha expedido previamente.
The file showed that Hidrandina had already granted the complainant the electrical feasibility and design point, the project approval and the certificate of completion of works with commissioning, expressly validating compliance with the applicable technical regulations; the polygonal plan, moreover, had already been delivered at the start of the procedure. The Chamber dismissed Hidrandina's argument regarding an alleged differentiated technical regime arising from the expansion of its concession area, specifying that the prohibition in article 40 admits no exceptions or weighing of reasonableness or specialty and also applies to special procedures.
Finally, the inapplicability of the barriers to the specific case was upheld.
Relevance
No entity (including public service concessionaires) may require regulated parties to resubmit documents or procedures that the entity itself has already generated, approved or holds, even when it is a procedure different from the one that gave rise to those documents. The prohibition in article 40 of the TUO of Law 27444 is of general application and does not yield to allegations of technical specialty or subsequent regulatory changes.
6. A municipality cannot disregard an automatic approval if it did not raise observations when the application was filed:
Resolución 0010-2026/CEB-INDECOPI-PIU | 12 de agosto de 2026
Sites del Perú S.A.C. contra Municipalidad Provincial de Talara
Bureaucratic barrier analyzed
The disregard of the automatic approval that would have operated with respect to the application for the installation of telecommunications infrastructure filed on August 5, 2024, embodied in four administrative acts.
What did INDECOPI decide?
The Commission declared the disregard of the automatic approval an illegal bureaucratic barrier. Pursuant to article 31 of the TUO of Law 27444 and article 5 of Law 30228 (which amended Law 29022), the installation of telecommunications infrastructure is subject to an automatic approval procedure, without prejudice to subsequent inspection; that is, it is enough to file the application without the receiving unit raising observations at that time.
In this specific case, the Municipality did not prove that it had raised observations on the application filed on August 5, 2024 (which bore a receipt stamp, file number and time of delivery), nor that it had granted the two-business-day period to cure defects required by article 125 of the TUO of Law 27444 in the event of defects in the application.
Therefore, the automatic approval operated from the very moment of filing, and the subsequent acts that disregarded it (by declaring it inadmissible, sanctioning the installation as unauthorized and upholding the sanction on appeal) contravened article 31 of the TUO of Law 27444.
The barrier was declared inapplicable to the complainant's specific case, specifying that the Municipality retains its powers of subsequent inspection and control and may assess the nullity or revocation of the deemed authorization.
Relevance
When the law subjects a procedure to automatic approval, the entity may only challenge the application by raising observations at the time of filing and granting the corresponding period to cure; if it does not, the deemed authorization operates from that moment and cannot be disregarded through subsequent inspection, sanctioning or appeal acts. If the entity considers the authorization obtained to be irregular, it must resort to its own nullity or revocation mechanisms, not simply ignore it.
7. A district municipality cannot require, for advertising signs, requirements outside the provincial regulation or charge for the use of public space through an ordinance that has not been published or ratified:
Resolución 0008-2026/CEB-INDECOPI-PIU | 12 de agosto de 2026
Publicidad & Comunicaciones S.A.C. contra Municipalidad Distrital de Castilla
Bureaucratic barrier analyzed
Three measures imposed by the District Municipality of Castilla to install advertising panels, embodied in Ordinance 04-2015-CDC:
(i) la exigencia del Certificado de Inspección Técnica de Seguridad en Edificaciones: Defensa Civil (INDECI);
(ii) la exigencia de copia de la carta de factibilidad de conexión eléctrica emitida por la empresa prestadora de servicios; y
(iii) el cobro del 10% de la UIT por metro cuadrado (S/ 535.00 por m2 al 2025) para instalar determinados tipos de elementos de publicidad exterior (paneles simples o monumentales, volumétricos, paletas o tótems, paneles o vallas digitales, globos aerostáticos y los ubicados en bienes de servicio público).
What did INDECOPI decide?
The Commission declared the complaint founded and the three measures illegal bureaucratic barriers. It specified ex officio that the questioned charge, described by the complainant as a “processing fee”, actually corresponded to a fee for the use of public space, without this affecting the Municipality's right of defense.
Respecto de las exigencias (i) y (ii), determinó que, conforme al artículo 79 de la Ley 27972, las municipalidades distritales deben sujetarse a la regulación que sobre anuncios y avisos publicitarios apruebe la municipalidad provincial; verificadas las ordenanzas de la Municipalidad Provincial de Piura sobre la materia, estas no exigen el Certificado INDECI ni la carta de factibilidad eléctrica, por lo que la entidad excedió sus competencias.
Regarding the charge, it concluded that it was illegal because Ordinance 04- 2015-CDC was not published in full in the corresponding newspaper, nor was it ratified by a provincial rule, as required by article 40 of Law 27972, so it lacked effectiveness to enable the charge. Thus, the Municipality violated the principle of legality.
Finally, the three measures were declared inapplicable to the specific case and with general effects. The Commission highlighted that, following the amendment of article 8 of the Anti-Barriers Law by Law 32587 (in force since May 8, 2026), inapplicability with general effects now also extends to barriers contained in material actions (such as the dissemination of an ordinance on a web platform) and not only to those contained in administrative provisions.
Relevance
District municipalities must abide by the regulation on advertising signs and notices approved by the provincial municipality, and may not impose additional requirements on their own. An ordinance that imposes a charge must be published in full and, if it is a district ordinance, ratified by a provincial rule to be effective: its mere dissemination on a web platform is not enough to enable it.
If you have any questions and/or inquiries, contact us:
Luis Diez Canseco
Partner
ldiezcanseco@dclegal.pe
Robert Venero
Partner
rvenero@dclegal.pe
José Carlos Gonzáles
Partner
jgonzales@dclegal.pe
Omar Alvarado
Partner
oalvarado@dclegal.pe
Roxana Arellano
Partner
rarellano@dclegal.pe

